Friday, May 18, 2007

Is Socialism a bridge to Democracy

This is in reference to a discussion Im having with a friend in relation to Hugo Chavez and Venezuela. Now my contention is that Socialism if morphed into a modern form could be a good starter type government for a 3rd world nation who needs sweeping reform. Venezuela is a good example of a 3rd world nation which was corrupt to its bone and elected sweeping changes in the form of Hugo Chavez who ran on the Socialist Ticket. Now its been 8 years since Chavez took over and since then he's been implementing his Socialist regime and instituting his extremely strong central government. Here are two big parts of the conversation I was having with him, and I did this over AIM, so I could save it;

" I wasnt going to allow for my degree to come into play but since you brought it out, I can share what I was told. Socialism can never truly be done on a consistent basis bc it does limit the rights of citizens and brings such international pressure on the country. Notice I did not say gives the people no rights, it only limits their rights. Venezuela is a country in extreme dispair and Chavez won the election on the socialist ticket, really these early moves by him are not at all out of the ordinary and articles like this are dumb because we all knew it was going to happen. Hell Chavez said it was going to happen, so should we be surprised? No. Now we all have a very bias view on which form of government works best, and we can argue that to ad nauseum, but the fact is that democracy would not currently work in Venezuela due to its corruption, it had to have a near dictator to pull it out of corruption. Remeber Socialism is not inheriently a bad govenment instead it has a horrible conotation. Strong govt power governments are good for corruption ridden countries to get out of Venezuela. It will however be up to Chavez to recognize when his country is out of its corrupt state and growing and relax his socialist grip and allow for more freedoms to continue the growth. Socialism is a bridge from corruption/dispair. It is by no means an end of the road measure."

also...

" Im no political theorist so I cant and wont speculate as to what Marx would of think of the current version of socialism, however it is my opinion and that of the professor who taught it that Socialism is a realistic bridge from poverty to freedom. I think Marx was wrong to say that Marxism was only to be used at the pinnacle of social evolution, I think its an extreme basic step, and Ill give you an example, which is a stretch yes but you should get the idea, and its started right here at home.

When the country was founded and the colonies started we left to escape what some might call dictorial rule (some would argue a socialist type rule even) in England. However we were only really able to gain the most crude and basic of individual freedoms. It is of my contention that we only benefited from remaining under English rule up until the time of the Revolutionary War. The English in fact did us a favor. If we had been on our own trying to start a new country we never would of got off the ground. We needed an extremely strong central government in order to both set up and understand the need for infastructure, and look what it produced? Such great thinkers like John Adams, Thomas Jefferson, among many others. Which allowed for us to take the hand off from Britian and run our own country into the Super Power it is today. Now fast forward to current day Venezuela. It is a country that is a mess and essentially has to start over. It was ran by corruption and gave nothing to the people or the country. In comes Chavez (who is by no means a saint, or an idiot) and he realizes in order for Venezuela to bring itself to respectability the government must take control. Now here is the trigger part about a good government and a bad government. There will come a time when the country will be ready to break off from its complete governmental control and begin to excersice its natural freedoms. Now in our case we had to take that by force, and we were successful in both getting those freedoms and we had the stability behind us to move forward. Venezuela is a long way from ready to take on a free society. It is of my opinion that Chavez (so far) is a good thing for Venezuela (Not the International Community, necessairly). And I agree TigerJ benevolent and dictator do not go hand and hand, unless you refer to some medevil kings, I think was even called Peter the Benevolent (or something like that). Could Chavez be that guy? I doubt it, but he's not domestic policy idiot, he knows what he's doing is good for Venezuela in the short run and will move the country forward, what I question is;
-Are his international talks/attacks for show?
-Where is his forward thinking at?
-What are his plans in 20 years?

I estimate that these questions wont be answered for another 20-50 years imo.

I dont know that Chavez is going to be a good ruler, Im just saying that Socialism isnt inherently bad and could be a smart move for Venezuela if done correctly."

Now Im not saying Hugo will be the type of guy to allow socialism to lead to democracy but Im saying that it could happen someday, somewhere.

No comments: